Fish house punch, older than the republic

Fish house punch, older than the republic

Rum, Cognac and a lemon-oil syrup in one bowl. Colonial Philadelphia could drink.


At a Glance

Time
15 min, plus 3 hrs chilling
Makes
18 to 20 (4-ounce) drinks

Story

The muddled sugar-and-peel business has a name, oleo-saccharum, and it is the oldest trick in punch making. Sugar pulls the fragrant oils straight out of citrus peel, giving you a syrup with all the lemon's perfume and none of its bite. It is why a proper punch tastes rounder than anything you can build from juice alone.

Ingredients

  • 4 lemonspeeled, fruit reserved
  • ¾ cup granulated sugar
  • 1 ½ cups Jamaican rum
  • ¾ cup Cognac or brandy
  • ¼ cup peach brandyor an apricot, plum or apple eau de vie
  • 6 cups cold water
  • ice ring or blockfor the bowl
  • nutmegfreshly grated, for serving

Method

A punch this old has earned its ceremony. It dates to an eighteenth-century Philadelphia fishing club that predates the republic itself, and it remains the correct answer to a houseful of guests. Start the peels in the morning and the evening runs itself.

  1. Put the lemon peels in a large jar or bowl with the sugar and muddle until the peels turn slightly translucent, about 2 minutes. Set aside at room temperature for at least 2 hours, overnight if you are organised. The longer it sits, the more perfume the sugar pulls.
  2. Juice the reserved lemons, about ¾ cup, and stir into the peel mixture until the sugar dissolves. Strain, pressing on the solids, into a large bowl.
  3. Add the rum, Cognac, peach brandy and the cold water. Stir, bottle and chill for at least 1 hour. On the peach brandy, the real thing is a dry, high-proof spirit, not the syrupy liqueur. If your shop has neither, an eau de vie does the job and earns its place on your shelf slowly, so borrow before you buy.
  4. To serve, set the ice ring in a punch bowl, pour the punch over and grate nutmeg on top of each ladled glass. One large block melts far slower than cubes, which is the whole secret to a punch that stays punch instead of becoming weather.

For a crowd

about 40 drinks

A batch already, but a houseful drinks a bowl faster than you would believe. Make a double batch and keep the second bottled and chilling, then top the bowl up rather than nursing a tired one. One big block of ice per bowl, never cubes, and start the peels the night before so the evening runs itself.


On the pass

More to cook

Pad kra pao with a lace-edged fried egg

Pad kra pao with a lace-edged fried egg

Ground pork, shallots and a fistful of chiles, glazed in soy, fish sauce and oyster sauce, then buried in a whole bunch of basil.

Serves 420 min
Nobody is kissing anybody after this peperoncini pasta

Nobody is kissing anybody after this peperoncini pasta

A whole jar of peperoncini, chopped and browned in olive oil, then sharpened at the very end with its own brine.

Serves 430 min
Crumbled tofu and beef stir-fry with asparagus

Crumbled tofu and beef stir-fry with asparagus

Crumbled tofu stretches eight ounces of ground beef to four plates, and browns in the fat the beef leaves behind.

Serves 430 min
Chicken piccata meatballs

Chicken piccata meatballs

Capers in the meatball, a whole lemon in the pan sauce and enough butter to make the two of them friends.

45 min
Stovetop lasagna with harissa lamb

Stovetop lasagna with harissa lamb

All of the lasagna and none of the layering. The noodles go in broken and the oven never comes on.

Serves 61 hr
Slow-roasted miso pork shoulder for a crowd

Slow-roasted miso pork shoulder for a crowd

Four ingredients rubbed on in the morning, an afternoon in a slow oven and a dozen people or more fed by dinner.

Serves 124 hr 45 min, plus 4 hr marinating
Shrimp and pork pita fried like shrimp toast

Shrimp and pork pita fried like shrimp toast

A shrimp and pork paste spread over a whole pita and fried paste side down until the meat sets and the bread shatters. Then it goes swimming in lime.

Serves 230 min
A whole head of cabbage smothered with andouille

A whole head of cabbage smothered with andouille

Cabbage cooked low under a lid until it turns sweet and buttery, browned andouille stirred back through and a splash of vinegar at the end to sharpen the whole pot.

Serves 41 hr 15 min
Tahini-butter gnocchi with squash, kale and crisp chickpeas

Tahini-butter gnocchi with squash, kale and crisp chickpeas

Everything roasts on one pan, the butter is cut with tahini and the yogurt stays on the side where it cannot soften a single chickpea.

Serves 245 min
Creamy tom yum rigatoni with shrimp

Creamy tom yum rigatoni with shrimp

Thailand's hot and sour soup, thickened with coconut until it clings to a noodle, with a sharp green sauce on top to cut through it.

Serves 240 min
Crisp rice cakes and sausage in a ketchup glaze

Crisp rice cakes and sausage in a ketchup glaze

Rice cakes fried until they crackle, then lacquered in ketchup and miso with the sausage.

Serves 450 min
A full course of Italian penicillin

A full course of Italian penicillin

Chicken soup's glamorous Italian cousin, with a spicy crumb and a cold lemon dollop.

Serves 245 min
Harissa shrimp broiled over a tray of greens

Harissa shrimp broiled over a tray of greens

The greens go in first with half a cup of water, and the shrimp only arrive once the broiler takes over.

Serves 440 min
Salt and pepper dumplings straight from the freezer

Salt and pepper dumplings straight from the freezer

Frozen potstickers and green beans, tossed at the last second in salt, sugar and more black pepper than seems wise.

Serves 425 min
Garlic noodles the way San Francisco does them

Garlic noodles the way San Francisco does them

Two heads of garlic, plenty of butter and three bottles from the cupboard, done in the time it takes to boil the pasta.

Serves 415 min
All 220 recipes
Add to your grocery list
in Reminders

Sends this recipe to an Artificially Seasoned list in Reminders, using a free shortcut.


Everything, by the handful

Browse the drawer

esc
↑↓ move↵ openesc close